ABOUT 7 HOURS AGO • 7 MIN READ

Please Don't Start Your Book Over

profile

The Modern Author

🚀 Want to write like Adam Grant or Brene Brown? The Modern Author gives you weekly templates, prompts & proven frameworks to turn your ideas into books, articles & authority. No fluff—just tactical steps to write with confidence. Subscribe now!

Howdy Modern Authors,

Last week, I told you about The Creation Event, a book I wrote, finished, printed advance copies of, and ultimately decided not to publish.

I got several replies to the article asking about my thinking. Asking how I felt. Asking what I was doing with the old manuscript. And I've been thinking about that decision quite a bit lately, especially because I've started working on a new book that incorporates some of the ideas from that old manuscript.

I meet a lot of people who have started and stalled... so clearly this personal experience struck a nerve.

And it's reminded me of a conversation I had recently with an aspiring author.

He'd spent years working in his field, studying the challenges people face and what might help them overcome those challenges. He'd done his own research, interviewed people, and collected a tremendous amount of material.

He'd also written most of a book... almost 47,000 words by his last count.

Which is a lot. He'd already put in the kind of work that stops most aspiring authors before they ever get close to finishing.

But as we started talking, I noticed something.

Most of what he'd written was about the problem. The research, the consequences, the things people were doing wrong, and why the situation was getting worse.

And I understood why. He'd spent years studying this stuff. He had a lot to say about it.

But I told him something that probably wasn't what he expected to hear.

"I don't think your readers need another book explaining why this is a problem."

They probably already know it's a problem. They see it in their lives. They worry about it. They've read articles and listened to podcasts about it.

What I wanted to know was what he'd seen that might actually help people do something differently.

So we started talking about the people he'd interviewed. The ones who seemed to have figured something out. The people who were approaching the challenge in ways that most of us hadn't considered.

And he mentioned an idea he'd been thinking about. A different way of looking at the whole issue, one that focused less on what people needed to stop doing and more on what they could actually create in their lives.

That stuck me... as a dad the direction hit me and as a professor, I thought it was teachable.

But there was an issue...

This isn't what was in the 47,000 words.

We played around with how that idea might become the foundation for a book. Instead of spending hundreds of pages explaining everything that's wrong, what if he helped readers imagine what getting it right could look like?

Suddenly, we were having a very different conversation.

I could imagine him giving talks about it. Leading workshops. Helping people think about their lives differently.

And he seemed excited about where it was going.

Then he asked the question I hear from authors all the time.

What do I do with everything I've already written?

I was honest.

I told him I wouldn't try to fix the manuscript.

I'd take it apart.

Not throw it away. Not start over. Just stop treating the existing chapters as if they're the structure the finished book has to follow.

Because he'd already done a tremendous amount of useful work. He had research, interviews, stories, examples, and ideas. There was no reason to lose any of that.

But there also wasn't a good reason to keep building around an outline that might no longer make sense.

I suggested he inventory everything he'd written. Break the manuscript into its individual pieces, then figure out what he actually had.

Once we'd designed the right structure for the new book, we could start putting those pieces back where they belonged.

Some of the material would fit almost exactly as written. Some would need to change. And some of it, frankly, probably wouldn't belong in the book anymore.

He'd also need to write new material, particularly around the solutions and possibilities we were now talking about.

But he wouldn't be starting from zero.

And that's a distinction I wish more authors understood.

If you've stalled... but don't want to give up on the book. This one may strike a nerve for you too.

Why I don't like the idea of restarting a book

I've worked with a lot of authors who've gotten stuck halfway through a manuscript.

Some have 15,000 words. Others have 60,000. Occasionally someone comes to us with a book they've been working on for five or ten years.

And they'll tell me they're thinking about starting over.

I almost always push back.

Not because their original book is necessarily good. Sometimes the structure is a mess. Sometimes the argument doesn't work. Sometimes they've written three chapters explaining something that should take three pages.

But they've also spent months or years thinking about the subject. They've learned things they didn't know when they started. They've talked to people, collected research, and discovered stories.

That's valuable material.

The mistake is assuming that because the book isn't working, the material isn't working either.

I think about it a little like an archaeologist.

When archaeologists discover something, they don't begin by deciding exactly what the finished reconstruction should look like. They first try to understand what they've found.

They collect the pieces. Study them. Figure out what belongs together.

And sometimes what they discover changes their understanding of the whole site.

That's pretty close to what I think authors should do with a stuck manuscript.

Before you write another chapter, figure out what you've already got.

You might be surprised.

I've seen authors discover that the story buried in chapter seven is actually the best opening for the book. Or that an idea they mentioned almost casually is much more interesting than the argument they've spent 30,000 words trying to make.

Sometimes the research is excellent, but the book spends far too much time diagnosing a problem and almost no time helping readers solve it.

That's what I was seeing in Friday's conversation.

And sometimes, as with The Creation Event, the story is great but the larger lesson hasn't come together.

These are different problems, but they all benefit from the same thing.

Getting enough distance from the manuscript to see what you've actually created.

What I'd do if your book is stuck

I'd start by leaving the manuscript alone for a few days.

No rewriting the introduction. No rearranging chapters. No polishing sentences.

Instead, I'd open a blank spreadsheet and make an inventory.

I'd list every meaningful piece of material I'd created. Stories, research, interviews, examples, frameworks, personal experiences, whatever.

For each one, I'd write a sentence about what it actually contributes.

Not where it currently sits in the manuscript. What it helps explain, demonstrate, or teach.

That distinction matters because you're trying to separate the content from the structure you originally gave it.

Then I'd put the inventory aside and ask a harder question.

If I were starting this book today, knowing everything I've learned from writing it, what book would I want to create?

I wouldn't begin with a table of contents.

I'd think about the reader. What do they already understand? What are they getting wrong? What do I know or believe that might genuinely change how they think or act?

And what would I want them to take away from the book?

Once I felt confident about that, I'd build a new outline.

Only then would I go back to the inventory and start finding places for the material I'd already written.

Some of it would be obvious. Some would need to be rewritten. And some would sit in a folder for another day.

I'd resist the temptation to squeeze everything back in.

That's probably the hardest part for most authors, including me.

We get attached to things we've written. Especially the stories we love telling or the research that took us forever to find.

But just because something was difficult to write doesn't mean the reader needs it.

And just because a piece of material doesn't fit this book doesn't mean it was wasted.

You can use it somewhere else.

I'm learning this myself

One of the funny things about writing last week's newsletter was that it made me think differently about The Creation Event.

For a long time, I thought of that project as a book I couldn't quite finish.

Which wasn't even accurate. I finished it. I just couldn't get it to a point where I wanted to publish it.

But now that I'm working on a new book, I'm finding myself going back to some of the old material.

There are ideas in there that I still really like. Stories I still want to tell. Questions that I'm still trying to answer.

The difference is that I'm no longer trying to make them support the original book.

I'm building something new and seeing which of those ideas belong.

It's a much better feeling.

And it's made me wonder how much time I spent trying to improve The Creation Event when I should have been questioning the book's underlying architecture. I've been having way more convos this time around... and honestly I realized a lot of the reason why it didn't work. It's been good, but also a little hard to admit I goofed.

I don't know. Probably more than I'd like to admit.

There's a lesson in there for me, too.

Sometimes persistence is exactly what a book needs. You have to work through the difficult chapters, the bad drafts, the moments when you wonder whether anyone will care.

But sometimes you can be incredibly persistent about solving the wrong problem.

And I think that's where authors (me included) get trapped.

They keep trying to improve the writing when what really needs to change is the book.

One thing to try this weekend

If you've got a manuscript sitting in a folder somewhere, particularly one you've been avoiding, I'd encourage you to pull it out.

But don't start editing.

Spend an hour taking inventory of what's there.

Like break it apart... every 200-500 words should be broken down and put into a separate document or spreadsheet cell or notecard. Seriously, like you're inventorying your spices in your kitchen...

Forget the chapters for a moment. Just look at the ideas, stories, research, and lessons you've already collected. Don't look at it as a book... look at it as content.

Then ask yourself whether you'd build the same book today.

Maybe you would. Maybe the structure is fine and you just need to get back to writing.

But if the answer is no, don't assume you've wasted all that work.

You may already have most of what you need.

You just haven't figured out how it fits together yet.

Happy writing, my friends.

Eric

The Modern Author

🚀 Want to write like Adam Grant or Brene Brown? The Modern Author gives you weekly templates, prompts & proven frameworks to turn your ideas into books, articles & authority. No fluff—just tactical steps to write with confidence. Subscribe now!